Talk:Puzzle Moppet

The assets are free, please read:

https://bitbucket.org/Knitter/puzzlemoppet/src/master/

"Asset files created by Daniel Frith (original author) are released under WTFPL."


 * Hi! The picture you posted is from this page on which the source code link says - All assets (textures, sound, 3D models) should be considered only *freeware*, and may only be used in "Puzzle Moppet" and may NOT be re-used in other projects. This is because a lot are from purchased asset packs with copyrights owned by various other entities. --GNUbie (talk) 23:56, 19 March 2020 (CET)


 * The game looks exactly like that and the bitbucket page says that the assets are freely licensed, but fair enough. Please next time try to explain your reverts. It's very discouraging to contribute only to have it reverted without explanation. (your other revert was also wrong and it was just a search away for license on the github page). Anyways I'll screenshot the game and upload my screenshot.


 * After some very close inspection, it seems that the quote that you cited conflicts with "Asset files created by Daniel Frith (original author) are released under WTFPL.". The licenses here https://bitbucket.org/Knitter/puzzlemoppet/src/master/puzzlemoppet/licenses/ don't seem to contain the licenses for the 3d assets, so unfortunately it may be that they are not free. Feel free to mark this game for deletion.


 * I contacted the author to clarify the situation, the only assets not replaced are the 3d models and those are very very simple (don't seem to be purchased from any asset pack). Hopefully they respond.


 * I'll try to be more verbal in my actions, noted, the last thing we want is to discourage contributors. Let's see if we get an answer that would allow us to keep this game. Otherwise it will have to be removed in a few days.


 * ps. Please sign your comments with ~ . --GNUbie (talk) 08:05, 20 March 2020 (CET)


 * Hey!, I got a response from the author, he told me that the 3d models are WTFPL and that he just didn't get to update the source, I'll quote the mails if needed if he gives me permission. I've also asked him to update the license information on the source if he can. Rampoina (talk) 14:20, 20 March 2020 (CET)


 * Good news then. I'll take your word you have his. I hope they do update the source as freedom is useless unless people know about it! --GNUbie (talk) 16:51, 20 March 2020 (CET)